Choosing the best whole home water softener and filtration system

Advertised prices, verified

How to specify a combined system

1. Test the water and write down the targets. Hardness, iron, manganese, pH, chlorine or chloramine and any specific contaminant of concern set the whole design. On a private well add a bacteria and nitrate test, because those two decide whether disinfection has to be part of the package at all.
2. Choose the filter stage that matches the target. Carbon for chlorine, taste and odor on city water, an oxidizing iron and manganese media for well supplies, a sediment stage ahead of either where grit is present. The filter is chosen first because it protects the softening resin sitting behind it.
3. Size the softener to hardness and daily use. Grain capacity follows from your hardness band multiplied by realistic household consumption, with a step up if you land between published sizes. Iron in the raw water reduces the effective capacity and has to be allowed for in the valve programming.
4. Plan the install as one sequence. Both units share a loop, a drain and a bypass, so fitting them together costs far less labor than adding the second one later. Confirm clearance to lift both valve heads and to carry salt bags to the brine tank without gymnastics.

Why the order of the two units matters

Carbon filtration goes ahead of the softener because chlorine attacks softening resin and shortens its working life considerably. On a well, an iron filter goes ahead of the softener because oxidized iron fouls the resin bed rather than being exchanged out of the water, and a fouled bed is a replacement job rather than a cleaning job.

The exception people ask about is ultraviolet disinfection, which always sits at the very end of the train. A lamp can only disinfect water that is already clear, so every particle removing stage has to be upstream of it. Any supplier proposing a different running order should be able to explain why in terms of what each media does.

Bundle or buy separately

Bundled packages from a single vendor are easier to specify and usually come with matched fittings and one warranty covering the whole train. They also make it harder to see what each half costs, so compare the bundle against separately quoted units of the same capacity using the table below before assuming the package is the better value.

Buying separately makes sense when your water needs an unusual filter stage that a bundle does not include, for example a specific arsenic or acid neutralizing media. In that case pick the filter for the contaminant first and the softener second, since softener choice is a straightforward capacity decision while filter media choice is not.

Common questions

Can one tank soften and filter at the same time?

Some units combine carbon and resin in a single tank. They save space and work reasonably on mild city water, but they give up the ability to service or replace either media independently.

What does a combined system cost installed?

Installed prices from local suppliers centre around $1,531, with the range in the table reflecting filter media type, softener capacity and how much plumbing the location needs.

Do I need both on city water?

Only if you have both problems. Hard city water with chlorine taste justifies both; soft city water with a chlorine complaint needs a filter alone.

Browse by system type

• Compare Water softeners on advertised prices
• Compare Salt-free softeners on advertised prices
• Compare Whole-house filters on advertised prices
• Compare Reverse osmosis systems on advertised prices
• Compare Shower filters on advertised prices
• Compare Countertop filters on advertised prices
• Compare Refrigerator filters on advertised prices
• Compare Iron filters on advertised prices